top of page

A Whistle-Stop Tour of the Midterms: What Actually Changes and What Do Markets Think?

Writer: Joshua Thurlow
Joshua Thurlow
2d
3 min read

The Democrats’ sweeping victory in the House and Senate came as a surprise, but what does this mean in reality?



This gives the party the 218 House votes and 51 Senate votes needed for a majority. However, it falls short of the numbers needed to override a Presidential Veto and does not hit the 60 Senate votes needed to end a filibuster, the Senate rule allowing unlimited debate to delay or prevent a vote.


What Does Their Majority Give Them?

The Democrats now set the legislative agenda. They decide which bills reach the floor and are ultimately voted on.


Democrat committee chairs will control investigations and hearings as well as issue subpoenas. Individuals will be obligated to provide testimony and documents to Congress, a powerful tool they can use to scrutinise Trump’s government.


However, legislation will need Trump’s signature, or two-thirds support in both chambers. Without this, he can veto any legislation put before him, a power he has expressed willingness to use when necessary.


Trade demonstrates how the Democrats’ power is limited. Sixty-six per cent of voters believed that tariffs hurt the economy, and Democrats have been largely critical of the policy, particularly in relation to Canada. However, removing the tariffs will require 60 Senate votes to overcome a filibuster and can still face a presidential veto.


Consequently, Congress may start with targeted concessions that are more likely to gather bipartisan support, rather than attempt to repeal the entire tariff regime.


The Power of the Purse

Crucially, Congress also decides the government’s budget and where it is allocated. Government funding must be renewed by the 11th of December, which falls before the Democrats take over on the 3rd of January; however, they still have leverage as the Republicans lack the 60 Senate votes necessary to overcome a filibuster.


The debt ceiling is also another crucial bargaining chip; only Congress can decide to raise the current $41.1 trillion borrowing limit, and the Bank of America estimates that this could be reached as early as February.  This will pressure Trump to cooperate if he wants to avoid default in the long term, or we may see a situation similar to the 2011 debt-ceiling standoff, when the US lost its top AAA credit rating for the first time in history. 


Foreign Policy

This is arguably where Congress’s influence is weakest. Trump, as Commander-in-Chief, retains control over military operations.  The extent to which Congress can dictate foreign policy lies in scrutinising defence spending and imposing rules on military funding. However, Trump could still veto these proposals.


Nonetheless, the election may present alternative constraints. JD Vance stated that the Iran War was the key contributor to the Republicans’ losses. This is broadly reflected in public perception.  Trump has since suggested there are no immediate plans for further strikes, which could suggest that electoral pressure has made escalation less likely.


What Do the Markets Think?

The markets’ reaction has been nuanced.


10-year Treasury yields fell roughly 10 basis points, before then reversing sharply following inflation data. This suggests that the midterms have not had a large impact on expected borrowing costs.


Oil tells another story: Brent Crude fell to a 10-week low, catalysed by an expectation that the US would not renew attacks on Iran, as mentioned above.


Equities have been on a journey, experiencing a post-election day rally, buoyed by the clear election result and expectation of reduced policy uncertainty. Yet just two days post-election, a global market plunge originating in America was sparked by fears that the Democrats would impose stricter regulation on the AI sector.

 

What to Watch

In summary, the Democrats have taken control of the brakes, but Trump still sits behind the wheel.


They have considerable power over spending, legislation and oversight, but it is unlikely they will be able to reverse Trump’s agenda in the near future.


We can cast our attention to the December funding deadline and debt-ceiling negotiations as the first key indicators of whether this seeming stalemate results in managed deals or an open confrontation.


On foreign policy, the election seems to have prompted Trump to reconsider the political costs of the Iran conflict; whether this will translate into a change of course remains unclear. Ultimately, the power is still in his hands.

Comments


bottom of page