Was Trump to Blame for Republicans' Midterm Defeat?

The scene was set as the 2024 presidential election loomed in the United States. Donald Trump took to the stage in Bozeman, Montana and issued a simple promise to rally his supporters behind: “Starting on day one, we will end inflation and make America affordable again.” A promise which resonated with voters and helped carry Trump to his second presidential term. Yet, in the wake of the recent disastrous mid-term elections for the Republicans, has Trump’s failure to deliver on his economic promises cost his party's reputation in the eyes of the public?
The BBC reported that almost eight in ten voters during the mid-term elections (79%) said the rise in inflation had “caused them and their family a severe or moderate hardship in the last year.” More than six in ten laid the blame at Trump’s feet, citing his policies as the main factor. Now it is worth noting that fuel prices specifically have been on the rise long before the 45th and 47th president secured his second term. External factors such as the War in Ukraine, which shot the price of oil by the barrel up to a peak of $127 on 8th March 2022, worsened the cost of living for not just Americans but a majority of the Western World at the time. However, Trump’s own foreign policies exacerbated matters by adding ‘fuel’ to the fire.
Iran’s blocking of the Strait of Hormuz, following the Trump administration’s decision to go to war with Iran in February, led to another hike in fuel prices globally, with the American people still feeling its effects today. In September, retail diesel prices reached a record of $6.52 per gallon, whilst food prices were 2.5% (CPI) higher than in September 2025.
Several states that voted for the Trump administration in the 2024 election rank in the bottom ten of the 50 states for average annual salary and standard of living. If higher fuel and food prices hit lower-income households hardest, then the voters Trump promised to help may have felt it most. Once promised an elevated approach to tackling the issues within the US economy, they instead suffered from the impact of Trump prioritising America’s global outreach. Perhaps the ‘blue wave’ that shook America’s political system on the 3rd of November 2026 came as a reprisal to a false promise made in 2024.
During his second term, Trump’s drive to “make America affordable again” seems to have slipped down the agenda. Consequently, the people who put their faith in Trump in the form of an electoral vote in 2024 were the ones to pay the highest price.




Comments